Even if possible, determining the cost of soil compaction may be the most challenging question we could answer today in agriculture. Soil compaction is described as what happens when you drive heavy equipment over soil repeatedly or when the ground is wet. That diagnosis is 100% correct; however, it involves much more than heavy equipment and repeated travel over a field. The equipment and travel over the field are related to the physical side of the three-legged stool.
No one talks about the chemical or the biological problems that contribute to soil compaction. The other two variables associated with soil health are verified with a penetrometer and psi readings that measure the same in non-travel areas.
Let’s dig a little deeper. Soil compactionmight not be the problem; it might just be “the symptom” of the problem. Soil compaction occurs when there is physical damage to the soil along with chemical imbalance and biological deficiencies. To go a step further, the physical (compression or destruction of the granular soil aggregates) damage occurs simply because the chemical and biological aspects are out of balance. We are taught that microbes and fungi are harmful and cause disease in the plant. Microbial, Viral, and Fungal blights do occur however these issues arise because the soil is unhealthy and the pathogens outnumber the beneficials. The beneficial biology in the soil is what creates the granular soil aggregates, which reduce soil compaction. Soil compaction is the best indicator of poor soil health we can measure, so it has received the “culprit” label. With soil compaction, drought and flooding issues are magnified, as excess water can’t drain and deeply held moisture is unavailable during a drought. Water issues, again lack of or too much, create stress in the crop, killing much of the soil’s microbial life and reducing nutrient availability.
Eighty-five percent of crop loss over the last 20 years was attributed to weather, specifically flooding and drought. We can’t control the weather, but we can control more of the water if we reduce soil compaction. This 85% equates to approximately $45 billion paid out to farmers. When we increase organic matter in the soil, we increase carbon as organic matter is 58% carbon. Carbon can hold ten times its weight in water. This carbon is our water storage during drought; it is our water collection during flooding. Water movement is also our nutrient movement in the soil, as soluble nutrients move with the water.
So back to the question, What is the actual cost of soil compaction? Soil samples that CaluSolv has collected since 2011 indicate that most soils across the US are compacted, and we, as land managers, are not correcting the problem. A tremendous amount of university and private research has shown that soil compaction causes poor development in plants, affecting yield and quality. Other research verifies that waterlogged soils are devoid of oxygen, ideal for fungal and anaerobic bacterial infection. This lack of oxygen also allows the proliferation of many different weed species. The actual cost of soil compaction may be impossible to predict as it increases weeds, causes both bacterial and fungal blight, reduces yield, reduces nutrient density and nutrient availability. The easier question to answer here is how can we correct the problem,
- Soil Health Evaluations every year
- Use lime to manage pH every year
- Use soluble calcium products like CaluSolv to increase the calcium to magnesium ratio for a minimum of 3 years concurrently.
- Between cash crops, uses cover crops to keep mycorrhizal fungi healthy.
To move in the right direction, you must first determine where you are. Start with a Soil Health Evaluation.

